Guest Post: From Poirot to Gamache – Stealing from the Great Mysteries

From Poirot to Gamache – Stealing from the Great Mysteries
by Patrick Kelly

What could be more boring than a clean, traditional mystery? Other genres might offer the loving embrace of a fantasy romance or a chance to save the world from killer aliens. Why bother with a mystery?

Here’s my answer. Given today’s world, with its constant bad news, endless political grandstanding, and countless video streaming options, the last thing I want is a screaming zombie in my face. And given the high sales figures, millions of readers remain perfectly happy with the tried-and-true mystery formula.

Agatha Christie’s first Hercule Poirot novel––The Mysterious Affair at Styles–was published in 1920. Christie went on to write three-two more Poirot novels. Louise Penny’s seventeenth Armand Gamache novel was published last year. What makes those writers–and many others–so successful? Before writing my first Wintergreen Mystery, I examined this question and concluded that a good mystery must include three essential ingredients.

First, the story itself. The reader walks step-by-step with the detective, sorting through clues, interviewing suspects, and analyzing motives. If the writer is clever enough, the villain’s identity remains a secret until the final reveal, at which point, the reader logically concludes the solution was distinctly plausible given the clues.

Second, a fascinating central character is key to a great mystery series. With Bill O’Shea–the hero of the Wintergreen Mystery Series–I have stolen traits from both Poirot and Gamache. Like Hercule Poirot, Bill has retired from active service as a police detective but retains a keen interest in solving mysteries that fall in his path. Like Armand Gamache, Bill is a likable character inclined to give everyone a second chance. Like both Poirot and Gamache, Bill has a keen ability to discern others’ thoughts and motivations. Unlike either Poirot or Gamache, Bill is a self-educated blue-collar cop who intentionally left the city for a quiet corner of the world.

Last but not least, a successful series must pull its readers in with a captivating setting. When solving a murder with Hercule Poirot, the reader may find herself in an exotic location–traveling by train through Yugoslavia or cruising on the Nile. Armand Gamache returns time and again to the charming village of Three Pines in Quebec, Canada, where residents regularly enjoy good wine, excellent pastries, and engaging conversation. As for Bill O’Shea, he lives in the beautiful mountain resort of Wintergreen, Virginia. Set in the Blue Ridge Mountains, the terrain provides opportunities for exciting scenes on the Appalachian Trail, at towering overlooks, or on ski runs that cut through forests. Wildlife sightings are common, with comedic relief provided by the local black bear, Ms. Betsy, and the neighborhood groundhog, Mr. Chips.

Next time your social media feed spins your head around, treat yourself to a clean, traditional mystery. Don’t forget about Bill O’Shea and his friends in Wintergreen. Sure beats a screaming zombie in your face.

About The Book

The Overlook Murder: A Clean Traditional Mystery (A Wintergreen Mystery Book 2)

It’s a short walk to the overlook but a long way down.

The rich entrepreneur Damian Susskind has recently survived a heart attack and quintuple bypass surgery. Suddenly aware of his own mortality, Damian summons his family and friends to Wintergreen to share the latest plans for his will. Unfortunately for Damian, one of those in attendance bears him malicious intent, and by the end of the day, Damian is dead.

Retired police detective Bill O’Shea is asked to help the short-staffed Wintergreen police department investigate an accidental death. Forensic evidence soon convinces Bill that this was no accident. There is plenty of motive to go around and more than a few suspects–the difficulty is tying a single killer to the crime. Will Bill and his friends solve the case, or will a Wintergreen murderer go free?

If you love beautiful mountain settings, a charming cast, and intriguing plot twists, you’re going to love the Wintergreen Mystery Series!

Clean read: no graphic violence, sex, or strong language.

Purchase Links – Amazon – Kobo – B&N 

About the Author

Pat Kelly was raised in Yorktown, Virginia, graduated from UVA, and left the state to pursue a corporate career. After settling in Texas, Pat married Susie, and together they raised two daughters in the awesome city of Austin. With the girls now grown and gone, Pat has pursued a lifelong love of writing stories.

Pat has written eight novels–books one and two in the Wintergreen Mystery Series, the Joe Robbins Series of five suspense thrillers, and one standalone novel of historical fiction (The Sheila Stories)

Pat is the winner of a Beverly Hills Book Award and a silver medalist for the Wishing Shelf Book Awards for adult fiction. He serves as Membership Chair of the Heart of Texas Chapter of Sisters in Crime.

Author Links

Webpage      Facebook    Twitter     Goodreads   Instagram

More from Pat Kelly


June 15 – Maureen’s Musings – SPOTLIGHT

June 15 – Carla Loves To Read – REVIEW, CHARACTER GUEST POST

June 16 – Christy’s Cozy Corners – AUTHOR INTERVIEW

June 16 – Lady Hawkeye – SPOTLIGHT

June 17 – Celticlady’s Reviews – SPOTLIGHT WITH EXCERPT

June 17 – Brooke Blogs – SPOTLIGHT

June 18 – Christa Reads and Writes – REVIEW

June 18 – Cassidy’s Bookshelves – SPOTLIGHT

June 19 – #BRVL Book Review Virginia Lee Blog – SPOTLIGHT


June 20 – Novels Alive – GUEST POST

June 21 – I Read What You Write – GUEST POST

June 22 – Literary Gold – SPOTLIGHT

June 23 – Escape With Dollycas Into A Good Book – REVIEW, AUTHOR INTERVIEW

June 23 – Sapphyria’s Book Reviews – SPOTLIGHT

June 24 – BookishKelly2020 – SPOTLIGHT

June 24 – Novels Alive – REVIEW

Have you signed up to be a Tour Host?

Click Here to Find Details and Sign Up Today!



  1. Thank you for hosting The Overlook Murder and for allowing me to guest post today. Also, thanks for highlighting the book quote from Bill O’Shea’s encounter with Ms. Betsy the black bear. Up here in Wintergreen, black bear sightings are common.

    I love chatting with readers and will stop by later to respond to any questions from readers.

    Thanks again! Patrick Kelly

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you for sharing your guest post and book details, I have enjoyed reading about you and your work and I am looking forward to reading your book

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s